| Player |
Menace |
College |
MLS Team |
Draft (Round, Overall Pick) |
| Logan McDaniel |
2010 |
Loyola Marymount |
Portland Timbers |
2012 SuperDraft (4th, 65th) |
| Matt Kuhn |
2010 |
Drake |
D.C. United |
2012 Supp. Draft (4th, 64th) |
| Lance Rozeboom |
2007-09 |
New Mexico |
D.C. United |
2012 Supp. Draft (2nd, 26th) |
| Andrew Duran |
2011 |
Creighton |
Seattle Sounders FC |
2012 SuperDraft (1st, 15th) |
| Jason Griffiths |
2009 |
Kentucky |
New England Revolution |
2010 SuperDraft (3rd, 48th) |
| Justin Davis |
2007-2008 |
New Mexico |
Real Salt Lake |
2010 SuperDraft (2nd, 32nd) |
| Danny Cruz |
2008 |
Nevada-Las Vegas |
Houston Dynamo |
2009 SuperDraft (3rd, 41st) |
| Mike Graczyk |
2007 |
New Mexico |
Colorado Rapids |
2008 Supp. Draft (2nd, 19th) |
| Matt Allen |
2007 |
Creighton |
Los Angeles Galaxy |
2008 SuperDraft (3rd, 34th) |
| Joe Germanese |
2006 |
Duke |
New England Revolution |
2008 SuperDraft (2nd, 27th) |
| Michael Kraus |
2005 |
Creighton |
Kansas City Wizards |
2007 Supp. Draft (4th, 48th) |
| Chase Wileman |
2009 * |
Southern Methodist |
FC Dallas |
2007 Supp. Draft (4th, 45th) |
| Matt Wieland |
2005 |
Creighton |
New England Revolution |
2006 Supp. Draft (4th, 47th) |
| Chris Hamburger |
2003-2006 |
Drake |
Kansas City Wizards |
2006 Supp. Draft (4th, 40th) |
| Stephen Shirley |
2003 |
Va. Commonwealth |
Kansas City Wizards |
2006 Supp. Draft (3rd, 29th) |
| Corey Farabi |
2005 |
Drake |
Kansas City Wizards |
2006 Supp. Draft (3rd, 28th) |
| Andy Grunebaum |
2005 |
Kentucky |
Columbus Crew |
2006 Supp. Draft (1st, 3rd) |
| Matt Nickell |
2002-2003 |
Drake |
D.C. United |
2005 Supp. Draft (1st, 12th) |
| Tighe Dombrowski |
2002 |
UW-Milwaukee |
San Jose Earthquakes |
2004 SuperDraft (5th, 50th) |
| Frank Sanfilippo |
2001 |
San Jose State |
San Jose Earthquakes |
2003 SuperDraft (6th, 56th) |
| Ishmael Mintah |
1999 |
Creighton |
Los Angeles Galaxy |
2002 SuperDraft (6th, 69th) |
| Leo Krupnik |
2002, 2004 * |
Cal-Berkeley |
NY/NJ MetroStars |
2002 SuperDraft (6th, 68th) |
| Chris Brunt |
2000 |
Missouri State |
Kansas City Wizards |
2002 SuperDraft (3rd, 37th) |
| John Jones |
2002-03 * |
Sacramento State |
Los Angeles Galaxy |
1999 Supp. Draft (2nd, 22nd) |
| Kirk Wilson |
1998 |
Drake |
Dallas Burn |
1999 Supp. Draft (1st, 6th) |
| Ezra Hendrickson |
1994 |
Drake |
NY/NJ MetroStars |
1997 Supp. Draft (1st, 5th) |
| * = Drafted before playing for the Menace |
| Supp. Draft stands for the MLS Supplemental Draft |